Property Prices in Annadale, Staten Island (10312)

Analysis of recent property sales — NYC Department of Finance data, all 5 boroughs

Last updated: 03/13/2026
$748,000
Median Price
$813,816
Average Price
1,161
Transactions
$433
Avg. Price / Sq Ft

Average Property Price in Annadale

The average property price in Annadale, Staten Island (10312) is $813,816, based on 1,161 transactions recorded by the NYC Department of Finance. The median price is $748,000, giving a price range from $16,500 to $7,100,000.

The average price per square foot is $433.

Transaction Volume (Last 12 Months)

25-01 25-04 25-07 25-10

Recent Sales

Date Price Type Address Sq Ft $/Sq Ft
2025-12-22 $1,288,086 2-Family N/A Philip Avenue 2,577 $500
2025-12-19 $687,000 1-Family 156 Mcarthur Avenue 1,536 $447
2025-12-15 $1,350,000 2-Family 59 Newton Street 7,316 $185
2025-12-12 $1,350,000 2-Family N/A Sheldon Avenue 2,700 $500
2025-12-10 $875,000 1-Family 456 Holdridge Avenue 1,750 $500
2025-12-09 $949,000 2-Family 4396 Hylan Boulevard 2,089 $454
2025-12-04 $1,250,000 2-Family 162 Edgegrove Avenue 2,443 $512
2025-12-02 $580,000 1-Family 45 Ilyssa Way 1,553 $373

NYC Transfer Tax Calculator for 10312

—
NYC Transfer Tax
—
NYS Transfer Tax
—
Mansion Tax
—
Total Transfer Taxes
—
Effective Rate

NYC RPTT: 1% (≤$500K) or 1.425% (>$500K). NYS: 0.4%. Mansion Tax: 1% (≥$1M). Does not include mortgage recording tax.

Estimated Rental Yield in Annadale

2.6%
Estimated Gross Rental Yield
Based on median price of $748,000 and average Staten Island monthly rent of $1,600/month ($19,200/year).
Source: NYC rental market averages. Actual yields vary by property type and condition.
View all 1,161 comparable sales →

Nearby ZIP Codes in Staten Island

10301
Clove Lakes 10302
Port Richmond 10303
Bloomfield 10304
Concord 10305
Midland Beach 10306
Midland Beach

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average property price in 10312?
The average property price in Annadale, Staten Island (10312) is $813,816, with a median price of $748,000. This is based on 1,161 recent transactions recorded by the NYC Department of Finance.
How many properties were sold in 10312?
There have been 1,161 property transactions recorded in Annadale, Staten Island (10312) in the most recent data period, according to NYC Department of Finance records.
What are the transfer taxes when buying property in NYC?
When buying property in NYC, you may owe: NYC Real Property Transfer Tax (1% for sales ≤$500K, 1.425% for sales >$500K), New York State Transfer Tax (0.4%), and Mansion Tax (1% for sales ≥$1M, with higher brackets above $2M). Use the calculator above for an estimate.
What is the rental yield in 10312?
The estimated gross rental yield in Annadale, Staten Island (10312) is 2.6%, calculated from a median property price of $748,000 and average Staten Island rents of $1,600/month.